Culture 3 min read By Bethany Hadley
Cynthia Erivo carries Prima Facie, though the adaptation feels clunky
Cynthia Erivo gives a commanding performance as a criminal barrister in the screen version of Suzie Miller's play, but critics find the film's structure uneven and its stage origins hard to shake.
Cynthia Erivo gives a commanding performance in the screen adaptation of Suzie Miller's stage play «Prima Facie», but the film around her is widely judged to be uneven. Her turn as a criminal barrister who finds herself confronting sexual assault anchors a drama that many reviewers admire for its emotional force while questioning its construction.
The story follows a barrister who has built a successful career defending clients in court. When the legal system she has worked within for years turns personal, her certainties begin to crack. The film is built around that shift, and Erivo's performance is the element most consistently praised across the reviews gathered for this story. Variety, reviewing the film on 13 November 2026, described her as the reason to watch, while the headline of that review framed her work as a conviction, though not necessarily a conviction of the film as a whole.
The central difficulty of the project lies in translating a play that depends on a single, intense space into cinema. The question of how far to open out the material is one the adaptation has not fully resolved. Too little expansion, and the film can feel stagey, its dialogue and blocking carrying the traces of the theatre. Too much, and the film risks losing the intimacy that gives the original its power. Variety argued that the adaptation tends toward clumsiness in its structure, with scenes that do not always sit comfortably together.
British critics have divided on the result. The Guardian praised Erivo's performance and the seriousness of the subject matter. The Financial Times found the film's flat approach to adaptation a weakness, suggesting that the visual language does not do enough to justify the move from stage to screen. The Stage, reviewing the cinema release, described it as subdued, a judgement that points to a film more interested in restraint than in dramatic escalation.
The divergence in reception raises a broader question about the film's worth. Several reviewers accept that the structural problems are real but argue that the emotional truth of Erivo's performance and the subject it addresses carry the film regardless. Others feel the flaws are too significant to overlook. Whether the film's impact outweighs its shortcomings remains, for now, a matter of individual judgement among those who have seen it. Prima Facie is showing in British cinemas, where audiences will be able to form their own view of a film that critics agree is held together by one remarkable performance.
7
